Buzzkill: Trump’s commerce wars threaten America’s craft brewers already reeling from altering tastes

Article content material

America’s craft brewers have already got sufficient issues. Exhausting seltzers and cocktails are muscling into beer gross sales. Millennials and Gen Z don’t drink as a lot as their elders. Brewpubs nonetheless haven’t totally recovered from the shock of COVID-19 5 years in the past.

Article content material

Article content material

Now there’s a brand new risk: President Donald Trump’s tariffs, together with levies of 25% on imported metal and aluminum and on items from Canada and Mexico.

“It’s going to value the trade a considerable sum of money,” mentioned Matt Cole, brewmaster at Ohio-based Fats Head’s Brewery. Trump’ commerce battle “might be crippling for our trade if this carries out into months and years.”

Article content material

The tariffs, a few of which have been suspended till April 2, may affect brewers in methods large and small, mentioned Bart Watson, president and CEO of the Brewers Affiliation, the commerce group for craft beer. Aluminum cans are in Trump’s crosshairs. And almost all of the metal kegs utilized by U.S. brewers are made in Germany, so a tariff on completed metal merchandise raises the price of kegs. Tariffs on Canadian merchandise like barley and malt would additionally improve prices. And a few brewers rely upon raspberries and different fruit from Mexico, Watson mentioned.

At Port Metropolis Brewing in Alexandria, Virginia, founder Invoice Butcher worries that he’ll have to boost the value of a six-pack of his best-selling Optimum Wit and different brews to $18.99 from round $12.99, and to cost extra for a pint at his tasting room.

Article content material

Article content material

“Are individuals nonetheless going to return right here and pay $12 a pint as a substitute of $8?” he mentioned. “Our enterprise will decelerate.”

For Port Metropolis, the largest risk comes from the looming tariff on Canadian imports. Each three weeks, the brewery receives a 40,000-pound truckload of pilsner malt from Canada, which fits right into a 55,000-pound silo on the brewery’s grounds. Butcher mentioned he can’t discover malt of comparable high quality wherever else.

Trump’s tariffs additionally hit Port Metropolis in a round-about method: The levy on aluminum, which went into impact March 12, is inflicting large brewers to modify from aluminum cans to bottles. Port Metropolis, which bottles 70% of its beer, discovered itself unable to get bottles.

“Our bottle provider is reducing us off on the finish of the month,” Butcher mentioned. “That caught us unexpectedly.”

Article content material

Fats Head’s Brewery will get its barley from Canada. Cole mentioned it may shift to sources in Idaho and Montana, however the transport logistics are extra sophisticated. And Trump’s tariffs, by placing Canadian barley at a aggressive drawback, would permit U.S. producers to boost home costs.

Fats Head’s is making an attempt to mitigate the affect of the tariffs. Anticipating greater aluminum costs, as an example, the brewery stockpiled beer cans — which it will get from a U.S. provider — and now has 3 million cans in its warehouse, 30% of what it wants yearly. It has additionally shifted manufacturing to painted cans, that are cheaper than these with shrink-wrapped movie sleeves.

In Arizona, some brewers are already eliminating or decreasing the beers they provide in aluminum cans to chop prices, mentioned Cale Aylsworth, the director of gross sales and relations at O.H.S.O. Brewery and Distillery and president of the Arizona Craft Brewers Guild.

Article content material

“This can be a blow to Arizona craft. I hate to see much less native choices on the shelf,” Aylsworth mentioned.

Some brewers have additionally misplaced entry to retailer cabinets from one large buyer: Canada, which is the highest overseas marketplace for U.S. craft beer, accounting for nearly 38% of exports. However Canadians are livid that Trump focused their merchandise, and Canadian importers have been cancelling orders and pulling U.S. beer off retailer cabinets.

The tariffs come at an already tough time for brewers.

After years of regular development — the variety of U.S. breweries greater than doubled to 9,736 between 2014 and 2024 — the trade is struggling to compete with seltzers and different drinks and to win over youthful prospects. In 2024, brewery closings outnumbered openings for the primary time because the mid-2000s, Watson of the Brewers Affiliation mentioned. He estimates that U.S. craft beer manufacturing dipped 2% to three% final yr.

Article content material

“Craft brewing had a interval of phenomenal development, however we aren’t in that period anymore,” he mentioned. “We’re in a extra mature market.”

Port Metropolis’s manufacturing peaked in 2019 at 16,000 barrels of beer — equal to 220,000 instances. Then COVID hit and hammered the corporate’s draft beer enterprise in bars and eating places. The comeback has been gradual. Butcher expects Port Metropolis to provide 13,000 barrels this yr.

The brewery seeks to set itself aside by emphasizing its award-winning brews. In 2015, Port Metropolis was named small brewery of the yr on the Nice American Beer Competition. Nevertheless it isn’t simple with import taxes threatening to boost the price of substances and packaging.

“It’s onerous sufficient to run a small enterprise when your provide chain is in intact,” he mentioned. And the erratic method that Trump has rolled out the taxes — saying them, then suspending them, then threatening new ones — has made it much more tough to plan.

Article content material

“The unpredictability simply injects a component of chaos,” Butcher mentioned.

Aylsworth, in Arizona, mentioned large brewers have entire groups of individuals to calculate the affect of tariffs, however smaller brewers should stretch their assets to navigate them. That’s on high of the opposite complexities of working a brewery, from zoning legal guidelines to licensing permits to labor shortages.

However for a lot of brewers, the heaviest burden proper now’s decrease gross sales as prospects in the reduction of on beer, Aylsworth mentioned. That’s why many brewers try onerous to not increase costs.

“In in the present day’s world, with the financial system and the excessive degree of uncertainty, individuals are spending much less,” Cole mentioned. “Beer is an inexpensive luxurious, and we need to ensure that we don’t lose that.”

Article content material